Jump to content

brobin

Member
  • Posts

    14077
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    21

Posts posted by brobin

  1. this has all the makings of a mid season issue...

    i would rather koivu get the surgery right now! That is a ticking time bomb that will truely suck for the playoffs.

    There are two big risks.. his play suffers from this due to the bluriness (he is a passer, they need vision!) but he makes it through the season. That is not great, since we need Koivu at his BEST. We need him to play better then last year.

    The second risk is that this becomes apparent to them, or the situation gets worse, and he ends up taking the second half of the season off for surgery. Even if he comes back for the playoffs, if we make it without him, he will be rusty.

    All I can say is keep your fingers crossed on this one. :(

    Brobin

  2. I think last season's playoff collapse shows that Koivu deserves 5 stars. He's not a legit #1 center and not an elite player in the league, but he is vital to the team's success. The healthier Saku stays, the better the team does.

    I disagree. Nothing against Koivu, but last year's playoffs didn't prove that Saku is a God in any way. He was playing average to poor (for Koivu) in the first few games. Yes, it would have helped if he was still in the series, possibly might have made the difference. HOWEVER..

    The turning point in that series was a change in goaltenders. Period. Koivu or no Koivu, Gerber was a red light flasher in the first two games and Ward completely stoned the Habs. He also went on to win the Conn Smythe.

    I still don't get why people think that Koivu leaving was the difference. The habs had tonnes of scoring chances in the third period after he left, but Ward was outstanding. It never helps when your Captain goes down, or your first line center (it allowed Carolina to focus on Ribs/Kovy). That said, Ward was the difference.

    Brobin

  3. I think is it a bit steep, but not overly so. It would have been worse if the deal was for 3 or 4 years.

    I am a bit concerned that Huet had a great, but perhaps not repeatable, 40 games. Huet has a tendancy to be slow getting across, which will be exploited next season. I don't think he will suck, but he was never as good as Theo was when Theo had his amazing season.

    If people remember back, Theo was behind a horrible team and was pulling off amazing saves. He was just an incredible talent, and look where he is now... It happens a lot with goalies...

    Huet had a better team in front then Theo did a few years ago, and in my opinion, was solid, not spectacular. He was certainly more consistent then Theo, which is worth a lot.

    I would like to see Gainey hold on to Aebi for a bit. First, its protection if Huet falters. Aebi will be out to prove he is a number 1, Huet will still be counting his money... Second, we all know that as the season goes on and Goalies crumble, the value of a good goalie goes up. For example, in a few months, Toronto may be desperate for a goaltender again (not that I would trade with them!).

    In any case, a good move, I sure hope Huet keeps playing the way he did last season!

    Brobin

  4. I have the feeling that they are over dramatizing it. Sure, there is a small risk he could have more issues with the eye, but it is a small risk. They have to make it seem dire so they can trumpet this mighty comeback in the fall.

    As Koiuv himself put it, this is not cancer.

    My main concern with his hockey will be how much of the summer he misses healing. This kind of injury limits his ability to work out (you don't want fluctuating blood pressure and exertion) so he is going to wither away. At his age, it will not be easy to get back in shape for the fall if he spends the next two months on the shelf.

    In any case, lets hope he recovers very soon.

×
×
  • Create New...