September 29Sep 29 1 hour ago, GHT120 said: It would take more than Dach to get Whitecloud, but I'd be open to adding value (maybe Struble, Xhekaj or Beck and a 3rd) Edmonton has a 2nd, two 5ths, a 6th and a 7th for the 2027 draft ... I'd roll the dice and ask for a first in 2030, four years down the road or even 2031 ... Bowman unlikely to still be GM by then so he might be open to it I agree it wouldn't be one for one, just that I think Whitecloud is who they target.
October 4Oct 4 6’6 222lbs Left Defence We don’t need this guy but I sure would like him Detroit is a dumpster fire
October 11Oct 11 If the Wings did trade Edvinsson for a quality forward could Montreal fill their need for a top 4 Dman? Probably not - Larkin doesn’t want to come anyway
October 11Oct 11 18 minutes ago, Prime Minister Koivu said: If the Wings did trade Edvinsson for a quality forward could Montreal fill their need for a top 4 Dman? Probably not - Larkin doesn’t want to come anyway Much depends on what Detroit is doing ... desperately trying to make the playoffs or rebuild (or at least major re-tool) ... the Wings already have two young, first-round RHD (Seider, Sandin-Pellikka) so Reinbacher not as appealing to them as to some ... Guhle is a legit Top 4 defenceman if they were willing to risk his injury history.
October 11Oct 11 No GM, dissatisfied players, lost 4 of 1st 5 games, looking like lottery team, i think as expected will miss playoffs again.
October 11Oct 11 28 minutes ago, DON said: No GM, dissatisfied players, lost 4 of 1st 5 games, looking like lottery team, i think as expected will miss playoffs again. THAT doesn't necessarily mean they won't do the stupid thing and try to sell the fans on a shot at the playoffs.
October 11Oct 11 1 hour ago, Prime Minister Koivu said: If the Wings did trade Edvinsson for a quality forward could Montreal fill their need for a top 4 Dman? Probably not - Larkin doesn’t want to come anyway Montreal can hardly afford to give up a quality forward (who would that be?) Montreal's biggest need is not a top 4 Dman (assuming Guhle can stay healthy and/or Reinbacher develops). It is secondary scoring.
October 11Oct 11 40 minutes ago, GHT120 said: THAT doesn't necessarily mean they won't do the stupid thing and try to sell the fans on a shot at the playoffs. All the signs there are of a skinflint owner. Such owners typically do not want to forego playoff revenue and therefore reject the idea of a rebuild. That was the story in Vancouver for 15 years.
October 11Oct 11 34 minutes ago, Habs Fan in Edmonton said: Montreal can hardly afford to give up a quality forward (who would that be?) Montreal's biggest need is not a top 4 Dman (assuming Guhle can stay healthy and/or Reinbacher develops). It is secondary scoring. I meant that can Montreal fill Detroit’s need for a top 4 Dman if they trade Edvinsson for a forward and Larkin for a Dman Is Engstrom enough if we added Zarovski and picks for example - probably not
October 11Oct 11 27 minutes ago, Prime Minister Koivu said: I meant that can Montreal fill Detroit’s need for a top 4 Dman if they trade Edvinsson for a forward and Larkin for a Dman Is Engstrom enough if we added Zarovski and picks for example - probably not Again, depends on what Detroit's "plan" is ... if they are trying to make the playoffs this season then no ... if they are looking at least 2 years down the road than Engström, Zharovski plus is a good starting point
October 11Oct 11 4 hours ago, Prime Minister Koivu said: I meant that can Montreal fill Detroit’s need for a top 4 Dman if they trade Edvinsson for a forward and Larkin for a Dman Is Engstrom enough if we added Zarovski and picks for example - probably not Thanks for clarifying, I misinterpreted.
October 11Oct 11 4 hours ago, GHT120 said: Again, depends on what Detroit's "plan" is ... if they are trying to make the playoffs this season then no ... if they are looking at least 2 years down the road than Engström, Zharovski plus is a good starting point The Red Wings last made the playoffs in 2016 which I believe is the longest active streak in the NHL so I am guessing futures are not what they are looking for.
October 11Oct 11 34 minutes ago, Habs Fan in Edmonton said: The Red Wings last made the playoffs in 2016 which I believe is the longest active streak in the NHL so I am guessing futures are not what they are looking for. Moving out Larkin and Edvinsson makes getting sufficient returns to stay in the playoff race difficult ... futures (albeit perhaps as near term as possible) would likely be the smart way to go ... but Yzerman officially leaving July 15th and the Red Wings still not having a permanent GM indicates to me that Christopher Ilitch may not be quite the "whiz" his Dad seemed to be.
October 12Oct 12 5 hours ago, GHT120 said: Moving out Larkin and Edvinsson makes getting sufficient returns to stay in the playoff race difficult ... futures (albeit perhaps as near term as possible) would likely be the smart way to go ... but Yzerman officially leaving July 15th and the Red Wings still not having a permanent GM indicates to me that Christopher Ilitch may not be quite the "whiz" his Dad seemed to be. That organization is such a mess right now so I guess it's hard to figure what they may do.
October 14Oct 14 Lebun asked directly if Larkin added Montreal after fans wooed him. The answer was NO We can put this to bed - or can we ? Lebrun goes on to question if Larkin is still on a losing Detroit team in three months would he change his mind! LOL RIP Larkin
October 14Oct 14 Wings don't play again in Montreal until almost a month after the trade deadline, so I guess the fans have done all they can.
October 14Oct 14 2 hours ago, Prime Minister Koivu said: Lebun asked directly if Larkin added Montreal after fans wooed him. The answer was NO We can put this to bed - or can we ? Lebrun goes on to question if Larkin is still on a losing Detroit team in three months would he change his mind! LOL RIP Larkin The whole thing was fun but silly. All talk of Larkin should have subsided once word got out that we aren't on his list. ?♂️ It's too bad, because he would have been perfect (even if 30 is a bit old for this group).
October 14Oct 14 1 minute ago, The Chicoutimi Cucumber said: The whole thing was fun but silly. All talk of Larkin should have subsided once word got out that we aren't on his list. ?♂️ It's too bad, because he would have been perfect (even if 30 is a bit old for this group). So this entire discussion is a reverse jinx and he will be a Hab by Christmas??
October 16Oct 16 This is just a fan account so nothing more than a talking point. If the Rangers did call about Dobes would you consider a deal that brings Zibanejad? 33 years old signed until 29/30 Cap hit 8.5 million Looks to be 70-80 points still We let Danault walk at the end of the season. More money would need to move to make it work but ?♂️
October 17Oct 17 18 hours ago, Prime Minister Koivu said: This is just a fan account so nothing more than a talking point. If the Rangers did call about Dobes would you consider a deal that brings Zibanejad? 33 years old signed until 29/30 Cap hit 8.5 million Looks to be 70-80 points still We let Danault walk at the end of the season. More money would need to move to make it work but ?♂️ Zibandejad is interesting. He’s a prototypical stopgap solution at C, buying time for Hage to marinade properly. But Dobes? Really? If this proposal came up before his recent struggles, it would have been laughed out of court. Meanwhile, we know Fowler has looked good and that he has pedigree, but we really have no basis for handing him the keys. Montembault hasn’t played a single game yet. If he can come back, and, after several weeks, show he’s returned to form, then we can start thinking about a move at G. But it should probably be a lower-level move involving him. You need two good G to win nowadays. Unless we have a whole lot of faith in a restored Monty, we’re going to need Fowler/Dobes for years to come, I suspect.
October 17Oct 17 2 hours ago, The Chicoutimi Cucumber said: Zibandejad is interesting. He’s a prototypical stopgap solution at C, buying time for Hage to marinade properly. But Dobes? Really? If this proposal came up before his recent struggles, it would have been laughed out of court. Meanwhile, we know Fowler has looked good and that he has pedigree, but we really have no basis for handing him the keys. Montembault hasn’t played a single game yet. If he can come back, and, after several weeks, show he’s returned to form, then we can start thinking about a move at G. But it should probably be a lower-level move involving him. You need two good G to win nowadays. Unless we have a whole lot of faith in a restored Monty, we’re going to need Fowler/Dobes for years to come, I suspect. I'm the only person here that thinks to trade Dobes is wise (overinflated value currently IMO). Lots of very smart hockey folks here so I’m going to abandon the Dobes suggestions because I’m probably wrong I have too much gambler in me
October 17Oct 17 10 minutes ago, Prime Minister Koivu said: I'm the only person here that thinks to trade Dobes is wise (overinflated value currently IMO). Lots of very smart hockey folks here so I’m going to abandon the Dobes suggestions because I’m probably wrong I have too much gambler in me For the right return ANYONE can be traded
October 17Oct 17 5 minutes ago, Prime Minister Koivu said: I'm the only person here that thinks to trade Dobes is wise (overinflated value currently IMO). I would be pretty much willing to trade any player on the team for the right return although I think Suzuki/Hutson are untouchables. I am not sure Dobes value is overinflated right now given his somewhat rocky start. Plus with Monty hurt it would sure put a lot of pressure on Fowler so a trade is very unlikely. One thing I totally agree with Commandant on is that goalies are voodoo so if a goalie's value was overinflated then a trade to solve another shortcoming seems like a reasonable idea. I am not sold on Dobes yet.
October 17Oct 17 I would trade Dobes, but only for a long-term piece. Our G situation, despite the terrible start in nets, is very good, structurally speaking. Don’t risk that unless you’re getting a serious and lasting fix to structural issues.
October 26Oct 26 From a hockey rumour site, but backed up by Friedman's actual podcast: What once seemed completely impossible might not be so impossible anymore. Speaking on 32 Thoughts: The Podcast, NHL insider Elliotte Friedman (@FriedgeHNIC) admitted there was a time when he believed Dylan Larkin joining the Montreal Canadiens had ZERO chance of happening. But he believes two things have changed: 🔴 The overwhelmingly positive reaction from Canadiens fans to the possibility of acquiring Larkin. 🔵 Larkin expanding his list of acceptable trade destinations, suggesting he’s serious about wanting a move. Friedman believes Montreal would have to put together an offer that makes sense for Detroit, and Larkin would still need to approve the destination. Nothing is guaranteed, and this remains hypothetical, but the conversation is certainly getting interesting. 32 Thoughts: starts around 34:50 for a few minutes: https://www.sportsnet.ca/podcasts/32-thoughts/heritage-and-hellebuyck/
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.