Jump to content

NCAA Free Agents


Commandant

Recommended Posts

Its that time of year (two guys have already signed with the Rangers and Islanders), here's a look at 40 College free agents to watch... in four parts.

Part 1 is headlined by Greg Carey and Austin Czarnik as we go through the list alphabetically.

http://lastwordonsports.com/2014/03/13/college-free-agents-class-2014-part-1/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't know, Condon's looking like a decent acquisition. He was signed as a college UFA.

I don't know either, but if i am going to put any stock in signing UFA's out of college i would like to see something a little higher on the food chain especially after a year---

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't know either, but if i am going to put any stock in signing UFA's out of college i would like to see something a little higher on the food chain especially after a year---

I'm just saying that the Habs didn't do nothing on last year's UFA market (even Matt Grassi with Hamilton last year and Wheeling this year was a college UFA). Interestingly enough, the one most of us wanted last year - Antoine Laganiere - is having a terrible season in the minors. In terms of the food chain, most of them only make it to the AHL level anyway.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm just saying that the Habs didn't do nothing on last year's UFA market (even Matt Grassi with Hamilton last year and Wheeling this year was a college UFA). Interestingly enough, the one most of us wanted last year - Antoine Laganiere - is having a terrible season in the minors. In terms of the food chain, most of them only make it to the AHL level anyway.

I am thinking DeKeyser type. Let me rephrase, given that the bulldogs will not make the playoffs again, signing top college free agents becomes problematic. If you can't compete for the few top free agents, all you are getting is roster fillers. Note that all these guys have already been passed over by multiple drafts and for whatever reason have come to light .Call me crazy but i prefer players that at least have an outside chance of making the NHL someday.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would you like any of the following players on your team?

Andy MacDonald, Chris Kunitz, Matt Read, Dustin Penner, Tyler Bozak, Torey Krug, Danny DeKeyser, Cam Talbot, Ben Scrivens, Joel Ward, J.T. Brown, Jason Garrison

All were college FAs in recent years.

As for Part 3, its headlined by Kenney Morrison

http://lastwordonsports.com/2014/03/15/college-free-agents-class-2014-part-3/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would you like any of the following players on your team?

Andy MacDonald, Chris Kunitz, Matt Read, Dustin Penner, Tyler Bozak, Torey Krug, Danny DeKeyser, Cam Talbot, Ben Scrivens, Joel Ward, J.T. Brown, Jason Garrison

All were college FAs in recent years.

As for Part 3, its headlined by Kenney Morrison

http://lastwordonsports.com/2014/03/15/college-free-agents-class-2014-part-3/

Yeah-- Thats what i am talking about.--- Do you think Grassi and Condon are even close? What's the chances of Hamilton signing a top free agent? if you were a free agent wouldn't you try to go to an organization that hadn't missed the playoffs, again? Do we have any need to sign anyone this year? No. Wait till after the draft and sign either an overager or somebody that was missed. Sorry guys, if we don't get somebody right off the top , i don't see any upside.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am thinking DeKeyser type. Let me rephrase, given that the bulldogs will not make the playoffs again, signing top college free agents becomes problematic. If you can't compete for the few top free agents, all you are getting is roster fillers. Note that all these guys have already been passed over by multiple drafts and for whatever reason have come to light .Call me crazy but i prefer players that at least have an outside chance of making the NHL someday.

So do I. That doesn't mean that if they're not signed by the end of March, they have no NHL upside. As for wanting to play in the AHL playoffs, that's not really a consideration for the top guys. Their preference is to start their ELC first and foremost and if they sign an ELC starting this year, they can't go down.

Some of the ones that have signed so far have gone to NYI (Czuczman) and NYR (Haggerty). Both of their farm teams are out of it like Hamilton but it doesn't matter since they're current year ELC's. That's the priority, not the status of the farm team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So do I. That doesn't mean that if they're not signed by the end of March, they have no NHL upside. As for wanting to play in the AHL playoffs, that's not really a consideration for the top guys. Their preference is to start their ELC first and foremost and if they sign an ELC starting this year, they can't go down.

Some of the ones that have signed so far have gone to NYI (Czuczman) and NYR (Haggerty). Both of their farm teams are out of it like Hamilton but it doesn't matter since they're current year ELC's. That's the priority, not the status of the farm team.

Just jog my memory will you? When was the last time we signed anybody of any consequence in this window? Seems to me that was a goalie out of Brown?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just jog my memory will you? When was the last time we signed anybody of any consequence in this window? Seems to me that was a goalie out of Brown?

Yann Danis is who you're thinking of. Brock Trotter was an NCAA FA, so too was Brendon Nash and both of them got into a few games with Montreal. The success rate on college FA's becoming NHL'ers is low, if you get one in a five year span, you're doing quite well. If you don't get an NHL'er but get one or two quality AHL'ers (which is where Montreal falls), you're also doing pretty good. Couple that with the fact more teams are taking flyers on NCAA-bound players in late rounds due to the extra time to sign them (4-5 years instead of 2) and the quality of the FA pool out of college is declining. Everyone wants an impact player but there usually aren't many (or any) and this year looks weaker than average. If they sign someone, it's highly likely that they'll be a piece for the farm over an NHL'er. It's still worthwhile though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yann Danis is who you're thinking of. Brock Trotter was an NCAA FA, so too was Brendon Nash and both of them got into a few games with Montreal. The success rate on college FA's becoming NHL'ers is low, if you get one in a five year span, you're doing quite well. If you don't get an NHL'er but get one or two quality AHL'ers (which is where Montreal falls), you're also doing pretty good. Couple that with the fact more teams are taking flyers on NCAA-bound players in late rounds due to the extra time to sign them (4-5 years instead of 2) and the quality of the FA pool out of college is declining. Everyone wants an impact player but there usually aren't many (or any) and this year looks weaker than average. If they sign someone, it's highly likely that they'll be a piece for the farm over an NHL'er. It's still worthwhile though.

Seems to me for the most part it is at best AHL fodder. I guess if you can supplement your AHL roster with veterans (college experience) without using up your veteran quota it makes sense. As you pointed out impact players are few and far between. I am not warm and fuzzy about what we have done recently.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yann Danis is who you're thinking of. Brock Trotter was an NCAA FA, so too was Brendon Nash and both of them got into a few games with Montreal. The success rate on college FA's becoming NHL'ers is low, if you get one in a five year span, you're doing quite well. If you don't get an NHL'er but get one or two quality AHL'ers (which is where Montreal falls), you're also doing pretty good. Couple that with the fact more teams are taking flyers on NCAA-bound players in late rounds due to the extra time to sign them (4-5 years instead of 2) and the quality of the FA pool out of college is declining. Everyone wants an impact player but there usually aren't many (or any) and this year looks weaker than average. If they sign someone, it's highly likely that they'll be a piece for the farm over an NHL'er. It's still worthwhile though.

Of course with him he just got destroyed by that injury. He was looking like he could possibly make it before that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There seems to be a lot of goalies inside that top-40. Even with Condon signed for next year and Fucale coming a year after, I think there could be room for one of them. (I'm skeptical that both Tokarski and Mayer will be back so theoretically, there's an opening for a 5th goalie to start in the ECHL.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I suspect every other team will be as well but good to hear nonetheless.

Maybe Habs have a couple too many d-prospects which his agent might see as a negative? I also imagine he is aware of his countryman Nygren's comments?

So I wouldn't get too excited till pen hits paper and even then most free agents are flops (as far as NHL goes).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bulldogs site reporting signing of Nick Sorkim to a PTO--- 6'3" converted center/ PPG this year---

I just find it hard to compare NCAA to pro play, but if Dudley-Timmins et al give him a thumbs up, must show some promise I suppose.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...