Both PPs are atrocious. Josi is a left shot though.
I question whether one of the keys to a PP is having at least one guy who is comfortable having the puck on his stick for prolonged periods of time while being able to defend it - puck on a string comes to mind.
A guy like that can exhaust the patience of a defender, coax him into making a mistake, thereby creating an opening for himself or someone else.
Kovalev comes to mind. Is that the last time we had a truly good PP?