I think almost everyone here would like to resign Evans. The question is, at what cost? At 3 million a year I sign him, at 4 million I don't.
No question his shooting percentage is not sustainable. If you look at his entire career he has averaged 10 goals and 21 assists per 82 games (including this year). He is also excellent defensively, a great penalty killer and by all accounts a great team guy. I am not sure who the closest comparable would be.