Jump to content

Commandant

Member
  • Posts

    23147
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    546

Commandant last won the day on February 6

Commandant had the most liked content!

3 Followers

About Commandant

  • Birthday 12/07/1981

Previous Fields

  • Favourite Habs
    Playoff PDO Bender

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Male
  • Location
    Nerdville

Recent Profile Visitors

80295 profile views

Commandant's Achievements

NHL Hall of Fame

NHL Hall of Fame (23/23)

3k

Reputation

  1. No... firstly forwards develop quicker than D so thats an unfair comparison and second, those forwards have been on the ice, not dealing with a serious knee injury. We clearly see its taken time for Laine and Dach to get over their injuries, even when healthy. We saw Caufield struggle to score for half a season after his shoulder injury. But we want to compare a guy who tore his acl to other players in the same draft without the injuries and call it a bad pick if hes developping slower as a result?
  2. The point is that development isn't linear and is different for every player. Every draft is different, the quality of the 5th overall pick one year to the next is not the same. Then you have different development time due to coaching, number of games played (injuries/covid/suspension), quality of teammates, quality of league, and a ton of other things. So every player is unique and these one to one comparisons are unfair, especially for a player who has played all of 46 games since being drafted.
  3. Michkov also spent a year in Russia post trade. He's a 2023 pick not 2024 like Celbrini.
  4. Everyone is available, again the key is WHAT IS BEING OFFERED. We'd all trade the 8th overall pick for Connor McDavid.... and we'd all say No to the 8th overall pick for Ryan Reaves, but without knowing both sides of the proposed trade, its impossible to say whether a trade should or shouldn't be made. That said, this is a better discussion for the trade proposal thread than the draft thread.
  5. The last four words of my post are the real key here. Without knowing... WHAT IS BEING OFFERED.
  6. I think this is an impossible stance to take without knowing who is available at 8 and what is being offered.
  7. Based on what I know today, I agree. But he seems close to playing this year and so playing 20 games and a playoff run in Laval could change my mind, or could cement my belief he should start in Laval. This convo could be really different in May.
  8. Yeah i fully expected them to.go down during the 4 nations break
  9. I said nothing about the person. The post makes no sense.
  10. All in the same post.... fowler is this and that and this and that but I dont know much about Fowler. Make it make sense.
  11. Lets criticize the team for rushing a player who is not ready when they havent rushed him yet and we havent seen if he is ready Cause hes ####ing injured. And lets bring up what management did with Mete, when none of the same management is in place. Make it make sense.
  12. Ehat the hell is Dobes doing on that. 3 goals on 8 shots. Make him the starter they said.
×
×
  • Create New...