Looking at our disaster of a year...
With Ducharme:
8 wins
12 losses by 1 goal
3 losses by 2 goals
22 losses by 3 or more goals
That's an (at least somewhat) lopsided loss almost every second game, which is indeed pretty regular. Although some of those are with one or two empty-netters.
With St-Louis:
12 wins
7 losses by 1 goal
3 losses by 2 goals
6 losses by 3 or more goals
That's a lopsided loss every 4.5 games.
Or by another measure ...
With Ducharme:
8 games with 0-2 goals allowed
18 games with 3-4 goals
19 games with 5+ goals
With St-Louis:
9 games with 0-2 goals allowed
12 games with 3-4 goals
7 games with 5+ goals
That's 5+ goals allowed every 4 games.
If it's every time, yes, it's a problem. But Montembeault and Primeau (or even Red Light Racicot!) have good games, too, the question is just the percentages.
Every goalie has bad games from time to time. Montembeault has them more often than Allen, but less often than Primeau. Is there a specific frequency threshold at which the young D-men's confidence will collapse?
Five-year average, yes.
February-April (15 games) has two games where he was pulled plus one significantly poor outing (5 goals on 32 shots vs Buffalo). So, the short-term average is less frequent.
We'll find out soon which one holds.
I don't expect Price to return for the Columbus game tomorrow. Could it be for the home game vs Islanders on Friday? I wouldn't expect him to start against the Caps' offence on Saturday night.
The number of return options is rapidly shrinking now. And of course it's by now quite possible that he won't be ready at all this season.
St Louis believes that it is possible for veteran NHL players to still learn and improve their hockey IQ. Maybe it's possible to improve a goalie's goalie IQ as well?
Looking at the 15 appearances in the St Louis era, he's about .919. Two clunkers (Arizona and Winnipeg) but about half his appearances are .920 or better. Not a disaster, I think -- and good enough for a rebuilding year.