Not even in same ballpark on offense.
Five 20 g seasons out of 19 seasons, in the highest scoring era of hockey, when even a monkey could score 20 (e.g. Nilan)
And how did the Habs do vs Oilers-Pitt, they regularly got lit up by 99 & 66, is why the Habs only won once in the 80s and that was a very unexpected win due to play of a real hall of famer in Roy, not Carbonneau. And in 92-93 he had a 17point season and 3g in playoffs, so again he wasnt key in that cup win.
Was he a solid hard working defensive forward and above average NHLer, for sure. H0F calibre, just dont see it.
(Also maybe why almost no one has even mentioned him being inducted, 2 or 3 other replies to this thread.)