
Habs Fan in Edmonton
Member-
Posts
7211 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
84
Everything posted by Habs Fan in Edmonton
-
2024-25 Montreal Canadiens discussion thread
Habs Fan in Edmonton replied to tomh009's topic in Habs & Hockey Talk
100%, they have a lot of money invested in Slaf now, they need to protect their investment. -
Yes, I have complete trust in Hughes, he obviously gave this a lot of thought and his patience paid off here. I break this trade into 2 parts: 1) Patrick Laine for free (cap space) 2) Jordan Harris for a 2nd round pick. Frees up a spot now for the young D and 2nd round picks are good draft capital Hughes obviously thought this was the best use of cap space. There is risk but I like it.
-
I don't think any GM is expecting Ceci to "find another level". It is possible however that some GM's think that Ceci is better than some of the armchair quarterback's on this board think he is.
-
I agree on this.
-
That's a big "IF" and as you have said and I agree goalies are voodoo. He hasn't proven anything at the NHL level yet.
-
Maybe Grier thinks Ceci can help the Sharks D for a year? Perhaps not all GM's think Ceci is as bad as many here think he is. The Sharks should be much improved, added some good veterans plus Will Smith and Celebrini should be fun to watch.
-
Agreed, the Oilers did well here.
-
Ceci to San Jose. Looks like the Oilers are matching
-
That's very true, it does make it more complicated for them.
-
Yes, I am assuming you would be willing to accept 2026 picks.
-
That's what I think. A 2nd rounder is likely in the 55-60 range which is not a big incentive to take on Ceci's contract.
-
Permanent Trade Proposal Thread
Habs Fan in Edmonton replied to dlbalr's topic in Habs & Hockey Talk
I am betting Laine is back with the Blue Jackets https://www.tsn.ca/video/blue-jackets-would-welcome-laine-back-if-there-s-no-deal-to-be-done~2979056 -
Permanent Trade Proposal Thread
Habs Fan in Edmonton replied to dlbalr's topic in Habs & Hockey Talk
I am sure Nurse is better with an Eckholm (who wouldn't be) or a Bouchard. Not sure that would apply to any other defensemen on the Oilers he would be paired with. -
Permanent Trade Proposal Thread
Habs Fan in Edmonton replied to dlbalr's topic in Habs & Hockey Talk
Comparing Ceci to the other Oiler defensemen (not named Eckholm or Bouchard) how would his advanced stats compare? He had a better +/- than all the others (including the overpaid Nurse), Kulak and Desharnais during the regular season. If they are all equally as bad as Ceci than it's amazing the Oilers made to the finals. -
Permanent Trade Proposal Thread
Habs Fan in Edmonton replied to dlbalr's topic in Habs & Hockey Talk
I think "this point in the rebuild" is a key consideration here. There are fewer pieces needed to complete the rebuild so Hughes is more likely to package draft picks to acquire that needed piece rather than acquiring more draft picks. However Hughes would likely consider adding another 1st rounder in the right deal as he can always package 1st rounders to move up. He was asked about acquiring another 1st rounder at the 24 draft, he said he was trying hard to move up in the draft (which he did) rather than trying to acquire another 1st rounder. -
Permanent Trade Proposal Thread
Habs Fan in Edmonton replied to dlbalr's topic in Habs & Hockey Talk
I understand your point. I just think that for Hughes to use up his last retention spot this early, nothing less than a 1st round pick would have to be involved as there is a reasonable chance of getting a 1st at the deadline. I don't think Hughes is that interested in 2nd and 3rd round picks this early in the year. -
Permanent Trade Proposal Thread
Habs Fan in Edmonton replied to dlbalr's topic in Habs & Hockey Talk
I think it does matter unless the reward is really worth it. I am pretty sure Hughes will want to have 1 retention spot available at the trade deadline as that is usually when you get the best deals. -
Permanent Trade Proposal Thread
Habs Fan in Edmonton replied to dlbalr's topic in Habs & Hockey Talk
I agree with this, getting the Oilers 1st rounder in 2026 (they traded their 2025 1st rounder) is likely not that big an enticement for Hughes at this point. He needs the young D to play. I think there are a number of other teams who are more likely to take on Ceci's contract for a year.