and the conn smythe trophy goes to...

[MAK]

this years winner isn't a clear choice like some of the prior years.

if the senators win it( they won't) it should be alfredson.

but who on the Ducks deserves it more ??

personnaly I think it's Giguère although he didn't have to be as stellar as 4 years ago

[BTH]

Giguere & Emery, no offence to the skaters

[Athlétique.Canadien]

Getzlaf, McDonald, Alfredsson, Emery and Giguere are IMO the considerations.

Giguere will win it I think if the Ducks seal it up in 5.

PS. Pronger should be a candidate but the NHL won't allow it to happen.

Edited June 6, 2007 by ATHLÉTIQUE.CANADIEN

[RobRock]

Never bet against the 'tender.

[dark_faerie87]

And it goes to Scotty Niedermayer!

[sakiqc]

i voted for alfie and scott

would have been odd if Giggy won his 2nd. He wasn't THE difference. He's good but he cannot be elevated as high as a Patrick Roy. Even the great Brodeur doesn't have a Conn Smythe. Nieds was a good choice and truly deserves the recognition. 4th Cup, 1st CS. He was all over the ice and their team leader.

[Pierre the Great]

And it goes to Scotty Niedermayer!

At least it wasn't Pronger. I would have :puke: