Jump to content

GHT120

Member
  • Posts

    10389
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    68

Everything posted by GHT120

  1. I think that was the "get him going so we can trade him" approach.
  2. I understand your perspective ... but it is dangerous to "fall in love" with players ... ANY player ... I am getting nervous about CC's contract ... he will get signed but I fear it will be for too much, for not long enough.
  3. I don't want him around the youngsters for that long ... Hoffman has two straight seasons of missing 15 games and just scoring in the mid-teens ... with his history and defensive deficiencies, unless he is on a 30++ pace I don't see him garnering more than a 3rd at the deadline ... not worth keeping him around IMO.
  4. I agree about not giving up assets to get rid of Hoffman ... but I would love to get rid of him ... maybe a little cap savings ($1.2M) for Washington and the Habs take on Mantha, who apparently is out of favour and also only has one year left ... maybe a little sweetener from the Caps (right to swap 2025 firsts) ... I just feel like Hoffman is not someone I want around young players
  5. Caufield + 5th + Florida's pick + 2/3 of Owen Beck/Joshua Roy/ Adam Engström/Jayden Struble/Riley Kidney/Filip Mešár for Keller + Cooley + 12th
  6. Was KK hurt in the last game? He didn't get a shift in the last 8:12 of the game, and had the least TOI of any Hurricane.
  7. We still, and will always, disagree about anyone's belief that draft lottery success can be engineered/guaranteed. I think that the "pure tankers", I'm not quite in that group, would perhaps not even have kept Guhle but rather claimed a few defencemen, with zero history of NHL success/potential, on waivers in order to have as little talent on defence as possible (the Habs has too many forwards to do anything similar up front) ... a porous defence increasing the ODDS of losing games, which increases the chances of lottery success ... HoGo did not, IMO, "tank" ... they just didn't try to win any more games than necessary.
  8. I think that anti-tankers like to interpret such posts that way ... but I don't think anyone supporting a "tank" ever thought it would yield more than the "best chance" at Bedard, and at worst 3rd overall if you are the worst team ... they just prefer that chance than hoping other teams leave a superstar for the Habs to pick in the teens.
  9. And nobody with an active EEG expects it would.
  10. Actually ... if they win they might even be able to move that boat anchor ... I wouldn't want to depend on him for three more years at $10M.
  11. Chicago isn't going to trade Bedard ... Arizona are in perpetual rebuild mode and I don't see an end-of first or early 2nd-rd pick as enough to get them to swap. So the POTENTIAL targets might be San Jose (4 years out of the playoffs after making it 18 of the previous 20 seasons) and Columbus (only 6 playoff appearances in their 23 years, 3 straight out after a 4yr playoff run that included one 1st-rd victory). San Jose faces a decision ... try to move Karlsson, maybe even Couture, and re-tool around Hertl or continue to lean on the veterans and go for the Cup ... ***IF*** the choice is the former, I think there is no deal as a late first or early second round pick just isn't enough ... ***IF*** it is the latter, then what does SJ need as the additional piece(s) in the form of NHL/NHL-ready players ... OR ... maybe taking a BAD contract off their hands in the form of Marc-Édouard Vlasic (3 yrs @ $7M, their 6D in terms of TOI, holder of only a 3 team NTC) ... in that case, could the Habs offer enough NHL/NHL-ready talent to not even have to give up the 5th pick? Columbus makes the most sense as a potential trade target ... they are a young team so the right NHL player(s) might entice them.
  12. Very fair question ... but her "management experience" is less than a year ... and it is in player development, not contracts, drafting/scouting or trade-related (which is not to say she may not have had input in those areas) ... she likely needs a bit more experience and perhaps to diversify into more mainstream GM roles ... but given a couple of more years she absolutely should be on every GM search list ... but if it was a recently retired NHL all-time great they likley would at least get consideration.
  13. Will Beck not be sitting out their first game (vs Seattle) because of the 2-game slew-footing suspension?
  14. Well ... who knows if making THAT right decision might have triggered more.
  15. NOBODY, despite your repeated claims, ever says tanking guarantees anything ... just that when done with foresight (e.g., not for poor or average drafts) it is the most likely means to acquire elite talent without having to depend on poor draft decisions by other teams.
  16. Forget Vancouver ... imagine if Edmonton had taken Matthew Tkachuk instead of Jesse Puljujarvi.
  17. Why 13 years? The Leaves tank started in 2014/15 for Matthews in the 2016 draft ... so the 2016/17 season was the start of their rebuild ... since then the Habs missed the playoffs 4 times, lost in the first round twice (once after the NHL created a play-in to include the 23rd and 24th placed Canadiens and Blackhawks, who just happened to be MAJOR media markets, as a "pay back" to their TV partners) and had the crazy Covid-season run to the Finals ... other than beating the Leaves in the playoffs not much to lord over them IMO ... it has been soooooo long since I felt the Habs were legit Cup contenders entering the season ... I badly miss that feeling. As a child of the 8 Cups in 12 seasons, 1968-79 Habs ... my measure of success is Cups, not playoff rounds ... of course the Habs "make the playoffs and pray" approach that has been in place for more than two decades depends on the latter being enough.
  18. Apparently a HIGHLY respected athletic trainer across the NHL ... wonder if he would like to fill the newly created position of Montreal Canadiens DIRECTOR of Training and Rehabilitation?????
  19. Nylander for Gallagher and Gallagher??? 😉
  20. That would be contrary to what Branch has done all year ... apparently there have been a record number of slew-footing suspensions this year.
  21. Being reported (also RDS) that Beck is suspended for two games, meaning he is out for the rest of the series (and, I assume, the first game of the Memorial Cup if Petes win Sunday).
×
×
  • Create New...