Wideman has a bad rep. But I don't think he's quite as atrocious as some people say. He does play protected minutes but he's not the only one. Let's look at the on-ice stats for the five D-men with ~50% (or higher offensiove-zone face-offs):
Clague: 2.59 GA/60, 3.17 xGA/60, 14.46 HDCA/60
Kulak: 3.02 GA/60, 2.37 xGA/60, 10.91 HDCA/60
Niku: 2.18 GA/60, 2.16 xGA/60, 9.83 HDCA/60
Schueneman: 2.10 GA/60, 3.39 xGA/60, 14.29 HDCA/60
Wideman: 2.81 GA/60, 2.62 xGA/60, 12.18 HDCA/60
There really isn't that much of a difference between those five ...