Permanent Trade Proposal Thread

[JGC21 69]

To Edmonton:

- Alzner, LD

- Shaw, RW

 

To Montreal:

- Lucic, LW

 

Hmmm....

 

I would do it only to give Gallagher his buddy to play with.

[Machine of Loving Grace 749]

1 hour ago, JGC21 said:

To Edmonton:

- Alzner, LD

- Shaw, RW

 

To Montreal:

- Lucic, LW

 

Hmmm....

 

I would do it only to give Gallagher his buddy to play with.

 

That would add almost $3M in cap to Edmonton, which in that case they would just keep Lucic. Remove one of them, maybe get a pick out of Edmonton for taking the bigger cap. Unless Bergevin pulls a, "If you are getting Milan Lucic, you don't ask for more."

[Metallica 48]

I got a question...... Why do we want Lucic?? His speed is gone and his power game is useless in today's NHL. Stop living in the past with this guy. Just be glad we didn't get stuck with that contract and he picked edmonton over us.

 

It always makes me laugh that people are willing to take a over paid guy to get rid of a over paid guy. You do know they have buy outs now. If we really want to get rid of these guys buy them out take the hit and move on.

[Meller93 195]

4 minutes ago, Metallica said:

I got a question...... Why do we want Lucic?? His speed is gone and his power game is useless in today's NHL. Stop living in the past with this guy. Just be glad we didn't get stuck with that contract and he picked edmonton over us.

 

It always makes me laugh that people are willing to take a over paid guy to get rid of a over paid guy. You do know they have buy outs now. If we really want to get rid of these guys buy them out take the hit and move on.

It’s not about Lucic, it’s about the potential to acquire the 10th overall through him

[Metallica 48]

3 hours ago, Meller93 said:

It’s not about Lucic, it’s about the potential to acquire the 10th overall through him

If you think you're going to get a 10th over all pick and lucic without giving up a top 6 player your crazy.

[Meller93 195]

2 hours ago, Metallica said:

If you think you're going to get a 10th over all pick and lucic without giving up a top 6 player your crazy.

Not if Peter Chiarelli is crazy

[alfredoh2009 112]

5 hours ago, Meller93 said:

It’s not about Lucic, it’s about the potential to acquire the 10th overall through him

ok, in that case, how about:

Pacioretty & Lernout for Edmonton's 2018 10th overall & Lucic & Caleb Jones

 

Lernout's future seems to be elsewhere than Montreal, and getting Jones would be a good swap for the CH.

 

[BCHabnut 292]

Pacioretty and 2 2nd rounders for nuge, # 10 and lucic minus 2.5 mill per year.

[Meller93 195]

4 hours ago, BCHabnut said:

Pacioretty and 2 2nd rounders for nuge, # 10 and lucic minus 2.5 mill per year.

If we consider Pacioretty-Nuge a wash (probably isn’t because of Nuges ages and center ability), two 2nds most likely won’t cut it. I think we’d have to send back a guy like Lehkonen Hudon or Byron, who are cheap, but replace that extra roster player, and still very useful.

 

Pacioretty, Byron, + 2 seconds for

 

Nugent-Hopkins, Lucic + 10th.

 

Chiarelli would have to want cap space a LOT to make that move.

[The Chicoutimi Cucumber 1359]

I've been banging the drum on a package centering on Patches-for-Nuge for a while. But if EDM likes Nuge as McDavid's winger, then the trade makes little sense for them, and I doubt their desire to move Lucic is strong enough to alter that equation. But I like pretty much any MaxPac-Nuge proposal in theory.

[alfredoh2009 112]

How about Pacioretty, Byron and two seconds 

for 10th, Lucic and Strome? 

 

I do not know how well Strome is progressing, but some articles on the web seem to indicate that he isn trending up as a 3C/2C

 

Drouin, Strome, Dabault, DLR, Poehling, Evans and the best center available at 10th could be an OK plan B if Tavares doesn't sign here 

[Meller93 195]

1 hour ago, alfredoh2009 said:

How about Pacioretty, Byron and two seconds 

for 10th, Lucic and Strome? 

 

I do not know how well Strome is progressing, but some articles on the web seem to indicate that he isn trending up as a 3C/2C

 

Drouin, Strome, Dabault, DLR, Poehling, Evans and the best center available at 10th could be an OK plan B if Tavares doesn't sign here 

One thing to be cautious about is Strome is another one of those sometimes winger, sometimes Center types. He’d be like adding a third Galchenyuk/Drouin. We need a bonafide Center. I know Nuge has moved to wing as well, but not because he isn’t a capable 2 way center, but because of chemistry with mcJesus

[DON 117]

Dougie Hamilton for Pacioretty ( if Hamilton as right shot, can play Left side?)

[Metallica 48]

I wonder if a trade for Ristolainen could be worked out?

 

To buffalo 

Pacioretty, there 2nd round pick , and a prospect

 

To habs 

Ristolainen 

[Commandant 1204]

Thats terrrible..... Ristolainen isn't worth that. 

[Habopotamus 90]

2 hours ago, DON said:

Dougie Hamilton for Pacioretty ( if Hamilton as right shot, can play Left side?)

I don't know if the rumours are true, but apparently he was hated by his teammates in Boston. 

[Machine of Loving Grace 749]

Word is that Lucic wants to leave Canada because he's tired of the pressure so we can thankfully cross him off the trade rumours.

[alfredoh2009 112]

12 minutes ago, Machine of Loving Grace said:

Word is that Lucic wants to leave Canada because he's tired of the pressure so we can thankfully cross him off the trade rumours.

youppi! 

[Commandant 1204]

13 minutes ago, Machine of Loving Grace said:

Word is that Lucic wants to leave Canada because he's tired of the pressure so we can thankfully cross him off the trade rumours.

 

I would have taken him if the Oilers were also including the 10th pick. 

[The Chicoutimi Cucumber 1359]

3 hours ago, DON said:

Dougie Hamilton for Pacioretty ( if Hamilton as right shot, can play Left side?)

 

He's listed as a RD. I know how tempting it is, but I don't think we should be making more these Drouin-style "square peg/round hole" deals. Unless there is solid proof that he's just as good at LD (doubtful) and that he's 100% happy playing the left side, we shouldn't make the trade. Otherwise, I would.

[Machine of Loving Grace 749]

25 minutes ago, Commandant said:

I would have taken him if the Oilers were also including the 10th pick. 

 

I mean, yeah, of course.

 

But I wouldn't be surprised if someone takes Lucic and it's not a Bickell style pure dump deal.

 

Blues feel like a team who would take him.

[dlbalr 937]

LeBrun on Lucic:

 

Quote

“I will say this: There’s a lot of people connecting the dots to the Montreal Canadiens because they were runners-up in trying to sign Milan Lucic two years ago. I’m told no way, the Montreal Canadiens not interested at this point in Milan Lucic.”

 

https://frshockey.com/nhl/oilers/lebrun-oilers-absolutely-in-trade-talks-on-lucic/

[Machine of Loving Grace 749]

Habs don't want him, Lucic doesn't want to play in Canada, perfect not match.

[Metallica 48]

22 minutes ago, Machine of Loving Grace said:

Habs don't want him, Lucic doesn't want to play in Canada, perfect not match.

Don't forget EK put it up on his site. Which means it isn't going to happen. 

[JGC21 69]

At this point any trade that MB makes has to be for a C or LD.  Anything else is stupid.  Enough already, it’s time we filled the holes on this team properly.